Thoughts on Vocation in Popular Culture

Credit to owner.

So, I was thinking about Frozen II the other day (possibly because one of my siblings was singing it? or maybe I was?) (this was before I left home, so more like the other month than the other day tbh) and it occurred to me...that two of the most recent Disney movies, Frozen II and Moana, explore primarily the theme of vocation. 

But, interestingly, from two different perspectives. Frozen II is more about the internal journey of vocation, what the person who is called goes through, while Moana is more about the external, if that makes sense...the resistance one gets from one's family in doing the thing that God wants you to do. 

If I'm being honest, I do more relate to Frozen II on this one. 


But semantics aside, what I find most interesting is that these are mainstream movies dealing with vocation, even if they don't realize it.

And when the MCs of these movies follow their calling, they become happier.

Just look at Elsa at the end of Frozen 2. 


Next to the first gif? There's no comparison!

And Moana at the end of her movie? 


She's doing what she loves, and it makes her happy. Look at that grin!

"Sam," you may be saying at this point, "okay, vocation. It makes people happy. This is basic knowledge. Why are you bringing it up? Why is this surprising?"

It's surprising because we live in a world that fundamentally has no concept of vocation. No concept of a special calling that's entrusted to each person. No concept of listening to God about what will make you happy. (Which is, at the root of it, pretty much what happens in both those movies, wrapped up in a slightly multi-theistic or multi-sub-theistic package.)

No, the world wants us to believe that we live in a choose-your-own-adventure story. Make your choices, do what you want, when you want. And if you want to choose to not have an adventure story, that's a valid option, too. 
And then they're surprised when they're unhappy.

The thing is, we do live in an adventure story. It's just a listen-to-the-storyteller adventure story. That's not a popular thing, for two reasons:

Reason #1: This world is one where where everything is about me. Not "listening to other people". No, me

Reason #2: Vocation is hard. Look at Elsa--she almost died multiple times! Look at Moana--she also almost died and/or was stranded, AND she had to fight a giant crab. 
As Sam Gamgee says:

"Full of darkness and danger, [the adventures] were. And sometimes you didn't want to know the end. Because how could the end be happy? How could the world go back to the way it was when so much bad had happened? But in the end, it's only a passing thing, this shadow. Even darkness must pass. A new day will come. And when the sun shines it will shine out the clearer. Those were the stories that stayed with you. That meant something, even if you were too small to understand why. But I think, Mr. Frodo, I do understand. I know now. Folk in those stories had lots of chances of turning back, only they didn't. They kept going. Because they were holding on to something."

This is just about as true for life adventures as it is for story-adventures, adventures wherein one is literally taking the ring to Mordor. No vocation is easy--each has its own challenges. Jesus did not say "have fun while following me." No, He said, "take up your cross daily and follow me." 

Suffering is, shall we say, about the opposite of popular these days. As our pastor says, the new "worst evil" of our time is suffering, not sin. People avoid suffering at all cost, rather than avoiding sin as they should. But it's only through the suffering that we reach the joy, the joy of being where we are truly meant to be, even if we are still carrying our crosses.

The joy of following God's will for us outweighs any sorrows that go with it. (I think/in theory. I'm still working on that, m'self. Plus I haven't found my final vocation yet, so...😅 But one of our priest friends says that he only became truly happy and fulfilled when he found his vocation. And that seems like a common experience. So I'm going with that.)

So, this vocation thing is such a fundamental part of us, part of the God-shaped hole of us, the restlessness, that modern movie makers are putting it into their movies, and including, in that, the fact that it takes suffering, and it's resonating with people. 

Do you find that surprising? I find it surprising. I kind of thought that the idea of vocation was a uniquely Catholic thing. But if you think about it, everyone has a vocation, even if they don't acknowledge it. So it's not that surprising that the pull, the yearning for something beyond, the feeling that maybe there's somewhere that I am meant to be, even if it's reached through suffering, is universal. 

And that's pretty cool, if you think about it. 


Can you think of any other mainstream pop culture things that have the theme of vocation? Which did you like better, Frozen II or Moana? (Hint: there's a right answer to this question) Do you have any thoughts, ideas, musings, etc. about your own vocation? Because if so, I'd love to hear them.

Comments

  1. SAAAAAAAAAM. I. LOVE. THIS. I hadn't made the connection at all to vocation and these movies, but I love it so much! As I'm sure it is for a lot of people, I really, really, REALLY struggle with vocation. So much so. On my current path I feel more peaceful than I have with any of the others because while it's not something big and glamorous, it feels like there is intent and purpose there. But maybe that's just temporary (like already, my favorite classes are not my needed ones, so that could be saying something.) and there is something better for me that God is planning and I can't see. Like Anne Shirley, it's right around the corner, and I just have to keep walking.

    And this makes a lot of sense of how I didn't love either of those movies, but the main characters are my absolute favorite. Because that's where all the good conflict is!! Considering how I am with snow, and how I did cry (of happiness. During "Show Yourself". Other people had sad tears in other places, but I didn't) during Frozen II, maaaaybe I like that one better? Maybe also because I hardcore relate to Elsa? I'm not like Moana, but I really admire her, so that pulls me to that one? This is so strange, I'm so used to the Moana vs. the first Frozen question. Then again, I am used to being biased against Frozen and am only coming to grips now that it's pretty great. I have a feeling that Frozen II is the "correct answer". Maybe I'm tired and have been having a lot of tests and am overthinking things. XD I'll go with Frozen II anyway, because while it is silly, I prefer all the side adventures and side characters as opposed to Moana.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sorry, the favorite question was probably supposed to be easy yet I wrote a whole paragraph. XD *facepalm* That's where I am right now, lol!

      Delete
    2. Awww, thank you so much, Chloe!! I'm also in the struggling-with-vocation camp, even in college, which is kind of the worst. XD But I have to keep reminding myself that God is in control, and the path that I'm going to take is up to Him, and it's going to be a good one as long as I don't plop myself down at the edge of the path and give up. XD

      It's true, the conflict is all with the main characters! (I can totally understand crying of happiness during "Show Yourself." Dang that song is good. *changes Spotify to Frozen II*) Haha, yeah, everyone asks Moana vs. Frozen, and I wanted to change it up...but I didn't mean to give you an existential crisis, sorry!! Frozen II is silly, but like you, I like it anyway. :) (But I'm going to conceal which was the correct answer until a couple more people have commented... *disappears mysteriously*)

      Delete
  2. I love your philosophical posts muchly. <3

    It's amazing to me how often I encounter ideas in popular culture - even, maybe, people not having the right answers but asking the important questions, recognizing the real struggles - and I'm like, "wait, I thought this was a specifically Christian thing??" XD

    Vocation is an especially interesting one because it's not actually something that makes sense from an atheistic worldview (I don't know about other religions), or at least, it doesn't make sense of how deeply rooted our need for a vocation, and to follow it, is. That's something even Christians can lose sight of, but it's crazy how happy you can be if you're doing what you're supposed to and how unhappy you can be if you're not - even if you're not doing anything wrong per se.

    Vocation is, incidentally, another of those things I like about Catholics. Like, Protestants have the concept, it's part of our worldview and all, but it seems we don't talk about it nearly as much as you guys? And I think that's a lost opportunity, because young people can get so lost if they aren't reminded to seek God's will in that specific way. It's important.

    I definitely like Moana better than Frozen II - but I can't for the life of me figure out if that's the right answer or not. XD I love what you observed about vocation in each of them (and funnily enough, I'd say I personally definitely relate more to Moana), but what gets me about Frozen II is that I'm just...Highly Skeptical that what was the wrong thing to do in the first movie (run off by herself, drop her responsibilities summarily in someone else's lap, and try to do everything alone) is suddenly the right thing to do in this movie because...because I don't know. I get that she's now running toward something not away from it, and sure fulfill the quest and right the injustice, but...maybe then go back and be a good ruler to Arendelle? Like you're supposed to? Why are you suddenly not supposed to anymore? I am Skeptical. (But that's just my opinion.)

    I don't know enough about pop culture to have any other examples, I don't think, but vocation and duty are pretty closely-linked concepts in my mind, and I think that's an interesting thing to think about in the Queen's Thief books. What the characters do for the sake of what they consider their duty, what it costs them, etc.

    Oh! And I went and saw Shang-Chi with my roommate last week, and THAT was interesting, because...I'll try not to spoil since you may not have seen it yet, but at the beginning Katie's mom is telling her and Shang how they're both so smart and so capable and could do SO MUCH with their lives and instead they're parking cars for a living? Go Do Something with your lives, kids? And then later on you find out more of Shang's backstory, and I was like, I can see why parking cars is actually a great life in some circumstances. Sometimes you can find yourself in the most un-glamorous places but they're still the places you're supposed to be. And you can still be happy and fulfilled and a good person making a difference in them. And you can't really ever know, looking in from the outside, for sure, that a person who's seemingly settled for less isn't actually right where they ought to be. Which kind of diverges from the movie but is still really interesting to me.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh thank you! I'm so glad! Because I love writing them. :)

      Yes! Because the thing about Christianity is that it addresses the problems of Being Human, but we don't always remember that; we might see them only as the problems of Being Christian. Which means that it's a surprise--often a happy one--to find that other people struggle with the same problems and questions!

      Exactly! It's one of the things that makes me wonder how people can be atheists; the truth of Christianity is so obvious just from looking around, to my eyes! And sometimes I lose sight of it, too, but it really is true that when we're doing what we're meant to, we're the most happy. And it just makes sense. Because OF COURSE God will know what will make each of us most happy and holy in life! And if we do that, we'll be the most happy!

      We Catholics do definitely talk about vocation a lot! It's definitely very important (and very emphasized, in the Catholic circles I move in) for young people. (Actually, we talk about two different types of vocation, do you guys? There's the Universal Vocation (or Call) to Holiness, and then there's individual vocations as well. Curious if that's a concept that y'all use, too.)(Probably I should've noted that in the post. A failure at defining my terms, lol.)

      Haha, I'll divulge the right answer in a couple of days! XD I'm enjoying watching people struggle over this, lol. I do definitely see that point of view about Frozen II! It was a fun movie, but the plot regression was kind of problematic. :P It makes no sense that suddenly the thing that was wrong is now right. (How typical of our culture. *eyeroll*) (I loved the music tho. I'm actually listening to it right now. XD)

      Vocation and duty! YES! What a fundamental link. And in TQT...*wanders off absentmindedly, pondering* *realizes that she's not done answering your comment* *bookmarks the pondering for later*

      Absolutely! Vocation is not guaranteed to be glamorous, even if, *cough*, it is in Disney. I mean, even leaving parking cars aside--being married isn't glamorous a lot of the time--lack of sleep, vomiting kids, messy house, &c. And people often see being married/a stay at home mom and unglamorous & "small", too, and like you said, you can absolutely be a happy/fulfilled/good person in that role, sometimes even better than in a "bigger" and more "glamorous" setting. (I haven't seen Shang-Chi yet. I am currently pretending Phase 4 Marvel doesn't exist. Change my mind.)

      Delete
    2. Okay, I like that way of putting it? Because holiness IS a vocation! I've never heard people talk about it in precisely those terms, though, so it might be a purely Catholic thing. (Or possibly just not something I've encountered? Honestly I couldn't tell you.)

      *still waiting for the right answer*
      I'm curious, do you like the first Frozen's music? How does it compare to the second one for you? (I really like the first one's music and wasn't a huge fan of the second one's - although The Next Right Thing is actually a really lovely song, clearly written by someone who has Been There, and the lullaby was pretty - but I wonder if this is an Unpopular Opinion, because I knew a lot of people who disliked the first one's music...even though it's delightful?? so why?? xD)

      Yeah. It's like, if you aren't doing something big /for yourself/, it's not worthwhile. When being a good parent is like the most worthwhile thing you could possibly do! Even if it's un-glamorous, it's MEANINGFUL. It makes me wonder, though, about people who are waitresses or who park cars...like what's the meaning in that? I feel like there IS meaning, but...I'm not sure how it works. I almost feel like there's MORE meaning in it by contrast...like if you did seriously bad stuff, and now you're a waitress, that has a lot of meaning for you and it might have less to someone who just lived a regular, fairly virtuous life and then became a waitress. I DON'T KNOW WHAT I'M SAYING. It was just a weird thought I had from the movie.

      (dude. Shang-Chi was great. Complex family relationships (one of which has a BEAUTIFUL resolution), hero who has a Past and guilt but instead of being broody is just a fun chill dude, his best friend Katie is hilarious and awesome, it has such a gorgeous fantasy feel, and there are lots of cool fight scenes and DRAGONS. Also it's basically a standalone and can be enjoyed and treated as such even if the rest of Phase 4 Marvel is no good. Did I do it?)

      Delete
    3. Yes! It's an excellent way of putting it. I'm now curious about whether some protestants have it and others don't, or if it's just a Catholic thing.

      *whispers* The Correct Answer is Moana. Good work. ;)
      I honestly do like the first Frozen's music. It was probably played too much for my general sanity, so I listen to it far less than the music from Frozen II (which I also really like) but considered in a vacuum where it wasn't played 24/7/365 for a year, it's really good music.

      EXACTLY! Unglamorous does not equal meaningless. In fact, glamorous is probably more meaningless than something like being a parent. I can kind of see what you're getting it...and I think some of the meaning in being a waitress or a car park-er is in the service to others--"whoever would be the first among you must be the servant of all" or something along those lines. Idk, just my thoughts.

      (Hm. You're tempting me, that's for SURE! A male-female best friend relationship? Dragons? Standalone? *groans* Okay, maybe I'll need to watch it. But is there multiverse? Porque no me gusta.)

      Delete
    4. Yeah...I don't mean to keep going on and on, but idk, I keep thinking about it, and I think...I don't think it IS the service-to-others that I'm thinking of? Like, yes, there is value in jobs that serve others, because serving others is valuable, but also...I feel like there's just VALUE?? In having a job and just /doing it/ day to day? Like, you know Milton? "They also serve who only stand and wait"? Kind of like that. The value is simply in that...this is the thing you've been given to do, and you're doing it. I CAN'T SAY IT, I'M SORRY. XD I just keep thinking about it.

      (Go watch itttttt. *shoos you* I don't...think there's a multiverse? Because no me gusta, either. There's a portal to like, another realm or another world or something, and I don't know if you would consider that a multiverse, but I wouldn't. It's more Narnia-esque. Also its only purpose is to explain the secret magical village and how the villain got there so it's not even a big part of the story.)

      Delete
    5. Ohhhhhh, I see! The value in doing what is set before one, no matter how unimportant it may seem! Doing the job God has given you, even if you don't think it'll do anything? That sort of thing? GOTCHA. That makes so much sense. (It's kind of like in The Silver Chair? With the Signs, maybe? Jill needs to remember them, even though they don't seem important? That's on a smaller scale/application/whatever, buuuuut it seems to sort of apply?)

      (Ooookayyyyy...I'll see what I can do. When it's free on Disney Plus, I'll seriously consider watching it, especially since there's no multiverse element. Narnia-esque is fine in my book. :))

      Delete
  3. This is a really interesting perspective! I thought Moana was more about the restorative power of empathy if it was really about anything but that makes sense. I did only see it once so I may have forgotten a lot. Loved hearing your thoughts though.
    I'll admit I didn't really like Frozen 2, I like bits of it but not so much the rest of it. I think sometimes having the movie be 'about' something (and the regression with the plotlines didn't help) sometimes makes a rather confusing movie. But that's just semantics on my part and not really related to the point you were making.
    Personally I think I've just been trying to enjoy life and feel comfortable about myself in it, I tend to spiral a little when I try to pinpoint what my purpose/vocation is because then I'm always worried that I'm failing at it or missing it. When really it doesn't matter, I could do anything technically. Because life isn't a movie with a climax in it usually, it's longer, softer, harsher, and less obvious than a movie.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    2. Although obviously we all want to be able to do the thing that we're passionate about, the thing that makes really content. The fundamental restless feeling we have that you mentioned that people put into things. I think it's why most of us do a lot of the things we do, which was you're whole point I think, wanting to find that thing and the reasoning behind it.

      Delete
    3. That could also be true! A movie can be "about" more than one thing, can have more than one theme. :)
      It's true, Frozen II was a bit confusing at times! I enjoyed it, largely because of the music and visuals, but I will say that the plot was not the best, to say the least!
      Hm, I can definitely see how contemplation of vocation can be hard/scary! But I do think it's necessary to try to figure out where one fits in the world (where God intends us to be, in my view), even if the process is scary and uncomfortable. That restless feeling is definitely real, and impels people to do things! I love what you said about life--it is longer, softer, harsher, and less obvious! That's why it's important not to expect life to be like a movie...but we can still take lessons from movies even while seeing the unrealistic parts.

      Delete
    4. True!
      oh I agree, I do like the music for the most part and the visuals.
      Also true, I do agree there's a level of searching that is required. I just more meant that even if you don't find exactly that 'one' thing, that doesn't mean you can't have, or don't have, a sort of vocation naturally.
      Agreed, there's so many parts to movies that I relate to or something about it visually suddenly makes something I've thought concrete.

      Delete
    5. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    6. Well, to a certain extent, yes! I do believe that each person has a particular path in life that's planned by God, but that doesn't mean that each person can't do different things, try different things, &c.
      Yes, that's one of the nice things about movies!

      Delete
  4. Interesting thoughts! I have had similar ideas on it, although I often think of it more as "purpose" than "vocation"... but purpose outside of loving God & others. I think it's important to note that vocations could perhaps be a seasonal thing? For example, if I feel 'called' to do something, and it makes me truly happy and I feel as though it's exactly what God has created me for, it's not the sole thing that gives my life purpose and peace. I think it changes over time... for example, if we felt like we were called to be an artist and create beautiful pieces, but we grow older and lose our eyesight, does that mean we have lost our purpose/vocation? No, it simply shifts into something else, depending on what our season in life is... if that makes sense?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Purpose is a valid way to talk about it, too! I think you're getting more into particular vocation; even within a vocation either to marriage or singlehood/religious life, there are specific things that people are called to, like, yes, as you said, being an artist, or for instance a doctor, a lawyer, a teacher, or whatever! And that could absolutely change. But you're right, it's not the only thing that gives life purpose--that's God!

      Delete
  5. Sam, I recently read a little book that was a treasure box for me, and it will be for you as well. It's called How to make decisions (by Fr. Mike Schmitz). It was extremely helpful because Fr. said that God will tell you your vocation when the time is right. That was just the best, it's just so good, and I feel like I'm (maybe) not worrying as much. Just telling you a little, and SAM YOU NEED TO READ THAT LITTLE BOOK! *figuratively shakes by the shoulders*

    Faramir
    P.S. I'm on my phone (srry) so that's why it's one large paragraph.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for the recommendation, Faramir! I've actually read that one already, and did find it useful. :)

      Delete

Post a Comment

Hi! I'm so glad you are here and taking the time to comment. I love all comments, even ones on old posts! I just ask that you are respectful and keep the comments section clean. Thank you!